明白嘅, 好多家長仲話覺得PHONICS幫到默書。
但我自己就覺得PHONICS係冤枉路, 因為PHONICS係教人估, 估D字點讀
表面好似睇串法就識讀, 但最慘連單音節嘅字phonics rules 都唔可以全部apply:
HOUSE >> MOUSE == OK
但 HORSE >< WORSE X OK
同樣地 NEW >> FEW == OK
但 NEW >< SEW X OK
例子太多不贅
仲有多音節, 輕重音, SCHWA, 外來字…等等 PHONICS完全幫唔到手
舉例:
輕重音: DISCOUNT, ADMIN 呢兩個字99%香港人讀錯
承上例, 當DISCOUNT你識讀, VISCOUNT你用phonics rule 拼就一定讀錯
小學中學嘅字太多, 靠"估"係死路一條, 我自己細個都係靠估, 所以鬧笑話, 我而家就想教我女唔好估, 呢個世界係有辦法百分百讀啱!
揀啱行車線唔止讀音OK, GRAMMAR應用上都幫到手 : ___ UNIFORM, ___ MTR STATION (ARTICLE 前者用A, 後者用AN, 呢D係有得解, 唔係好似我細個比人老點話係EXCEPTION)